|
First impressions count - and few are impressed by Heathrow Airport.
Whilst we British just grumble about delays as we depart on holiday,
for the thousands of overseas travellers arriving every day the
'Heathrow experience' proves to be the low point of any visit, emphasised
consistently in passenger surveys. Poor passenger conditions, out
of date facilities and queues and long delays are now synonymous
with Heathrow. It is a British embarrassment and its damaging reputation
is having a knock-on effect which the Government should take at
least some responsibility for addressing by holding the airport
operator, BAA, to account and by improving immigration control at
the point of entry to the UK.
Tourism is Britain's
sixth largest industry so attracting people to Britain must be something
we get right. Competition for inbound tourism is now global and
when our growth rate in the UK is compared with the global average
we under-perform by around 5m visitors to the UK each year, meaning
our tourist industry foregoes a potential £3bn each year.
So why are we
under-performing? BAA argues that extra security measures mean delays
are inevitable. However airports such as Washington DC or Singapore
face the same terrorist threats and are able to avoid lengthy delays.
It also points to the new Terminal 5 development which will undoubtedly
change Heathrow's service but will not come fully into play until
2011. This re-organisation also means that Terminals 1 and 2 will
be closed for refurbishment once planes have been re-allocated to
the new terminal. Whilst the new Terminal 5 building will undoubtedly
be more up to date and impressive than other terminals, it will
not improve the life of air traffic controllers as the airport is
already working to 98.5% capacity and this capacity cannot be increased
by a new terminal building. With a plane landing around every 90
seconds there is no scope for error and the system is prone to chaos,
as was evidenced in July last year when bad weather crippled the
airport for almost a week.
BAA owns not
only Heathrow but also Gatwick and Stansted Airports. It is timely
that the Competition Commission is reviewing whether it is now time
to break up this monopoly and introduce some long overdue competition
between London's principal airports. This absence of competition
has led to a lack of investment which lies at the very heart of
Heathrow's present shortcomings. Out of date baggage handling facilities
and a shortage of trained staff cause the confusion most passengers
now dread. Over 2,000 bags are misplaced every day.
Some 1300 take
offs and landings taking place daily, therefore processing passengers
efficiently is fundamental if delays are to be avoided. Yet, despite
its strategic importance, Heathrow has failed to introduce changes
seen at other international airports in order to manage increases
in passenger numbers and higher levels of security. Delays can be
so severe that some travellers on short-haul journeys can spend
longer in immigration queues, or taxi-ing to and from the terminal
building to the runway, than on their flight.
The absence of competition between London airports also means BAA
has been able to secure huge profits from duty free shopping malls
at the expense of investment (and space) in security clearance procedures.
Around 40% of BAA's profits now come from non air-related commercial
operations. There is a stark contrast between the acres of shopping
facilities provided compared with the limited space for scanners
and security checks. This imbalance, exploiting the passengers'
wallets verses pursuing efficient passenger processing, needs to
be addressed.
All the blame
cannot be laid at the door of BAA. Take Terminal 4. Around 24 large
aircraft land and deposit passengers between 5.30am and 7am every
day, flying in from all corners of the globe. Yet there are only
two immigration officers on duty during this period dealing with
non EU passports (leaving another half a dozen checkpoints empty)
causing a queue of hundreds of passengers to snake its way out of
the passport area and add an extra hour to the process. The Government
chose to double air passenger duty last February, providing the
Treasury with an additional £1 billion. It seems little of
this extra revenue has found its way to improve immigration control
at our airports.
BAA is responsible
for the largest and most important airports in the world but Heathrow
is out dated and is failing as a respectable gateway to Britain.
Our premier international airport is slowly turning into a national
disgrace and is damaging our international reputation both as a
strategic hub and tourist destination.
|